At 5:12 a.m. on April 18, 1906—one hundred and twenty years ago today—the landscape of San Francisco was permanently altered by a 7.9 magnitude earthquake and the massive fires that followed. Countless books on the Great San Francisco Earthquake and Fire of 1906 have analyzed the disaster from every conceivable angle: historical, geological, sociological, political, pictorial, etc. The quake has also proven to be a popular and durable plot device for mystery writers from soon after the calamitous event to the present day.
The events of 1906 provide the backdrop for a significant number of crime and mystery novels. In these works, the disaster drives otherwise law-abiding citizens to commit criminal acts, provides the opportunity for people to change their identities, exposes criminal activity to the harsh light of day, and shows up as the ultimate deus ex machina, providing a solution—sometimes a permanent solution—to a particularly sticky situation.
The first earthquake novel on the scene was Travers: A Story of the San Francisco Earthquake by Sara Dean. Although not a traditional mystery story, crime plays a central role in the plot. Published in February 1908, Travers is the ripped-from-the-headlines story of a San Francisco socialite named Gwendolyn Thornton who is awoken by a thief in her home. As she confronts the intruder, the earthquake strikes, destroying her house. After escaping—with the help of the intruder—to the safety of a refugee camp on Twin Peaks, Gwen learns that her rescuer, a British ex-army surgeon named Keith Travers, had been dismissed from his regiment following a scandal and forced into a life of crime. The earthquake offers Travers an opportunity to reclaim his reputation and standing in society. Written so soon after the actual earthquake, the novel features graphic descriptions of the city and its residents in the wake of the disaster.
The great California writer Gertrude Atherton used the 1906 earthquake to propel the plot of her one foray into mystery fiction—although the mystery in The Avalanche (1919) is more genealogical than criminal. In San Francisco, in the years immediately following the earthquake, Price Ruyler is married and has firmly established himself in business and society. After he overhears an exchange between his mother-in-law and a man known to have made his living as a pimp and a gambler before the earthquake and fire, he begins to suspect that his wife’s past might not be as innocent as he was led to believe. He hires a private detective to investigate and uncovers a plot involving blackmail, betrayal, and the consequences of losing an entire city’s public records.
Phyllis A. Whitney’s The Trembling Hills (1956) is a gothic romance/mystery novel set in 1906, where a woman's search for love unearths a dark secret involving a manipulative family and a sinister matriarch. The story follows Sara Bishop as she goes to San Francisco to pursue her childhood sweetheart, only to find herself entangled in a web of mystery, family secrets, and the devastating earthquake, which finally brings the past to light.
The British join the party in The Golden Crucible (1976) by Jean Stubbs. Retired Scotland Yard Inspector John Joseph Lintott is enlisted to investigate the kidnapping of Alicia Salvador—who is the sister and assistant of the famous magician, Felix Salvador. Lintott follows the kidnappers from London to San Francisco and discovers that the plot is part of an elaborate revenge scheme. He negotiates Alicia’s release from a Barbary Coast brothel and as they are on their way to reunite with her brother the earthquake strikes. This novel stands apart from other earthquake mysteries in that the mystery is effectively solved before the quake hits. However, the disaster does manage to tie up some loose ends, meting out punishments that Lintott has no control over.
Mignon G. Eberhart, who wrote over sixty novels in her long career, set exactly one story in San Francisco: Casa Madrone (1980), which takes place in April 1906. Mallory Bookever travels from New York to San Francisco in order to marry young and wealthy Richard Welbeck. When she arrives in San Francisco, she finds that Richard is an invalid in his Nob Hill mansion. In the aftermath of the earthquake, Richard is shot and killed. At first Mallory and Richard’s best friend, Scott Suydam, believe that a stray bullet fired by a patrolling soldier struck him. However, they soon suspect that Richard has been murdered in order to prevent his marriage. As the fire approaches, they relocate to Scott’s home, Casa Madrone, where they struggle to put their lives back together and unmask the killer.
Readers of Dianne Day’s Fire and Fog (1996) do not have to wait long for the earthquake to strike. The story opens precisely at 5:12 a.m. on April 18, 1906 as Caroline “Fremont” Jones, a plucky, independent typist-for-hire, is tumbled out of bed by the earthquake. At her office, she discovers several crates filled with Japanese artifacts, leading her to suspect that her landlords are involved in a smuggling operation. Unable to stay in her room or occupy her office, Fremont relocates to the tent city in Golden Gate Park and makes herself useful driving for the Red Cross. She also becomes entangled in uncovering the mystery of the stolen Japanese treasures. In addition to vivid descriptions of the quake and fire, this novel offers interesting visions of life in a tent city, the emerging importance of the automobile, the relief efforts, and the outdoor kitchens set up around the neighborhoods.
Michael Castleman’s The Lost Gold of San Francisco (2003) is distinct in the canon of earthquake novels—its plot provides a direct link between the Big One in 1906 and the “pretty big one” in 1989. In April 1906, the San Francisco Mint is preparing to send a large shipment of misstruck gold pieces to Denver to be melted down. In the chaos following the earthquake, the coins disappear. In 1989, the director of a museum slated to receive a donation of one of the 1906 coins is murdered. Reporter Ed Rosenberg, assigned to cover the donation, turns his attention to the murder investigation. As he reaches the end of the mystery, the Loma Prieta earthquake strikes, causing the death of the killer. Although this novel is filled with an incredible amount of historical detail, the central premise of the lost gold is fictional. However, an item in the San Francisco Chronicle written by columnist Herb Caen in 1987 inspired Castleman’s plot: a laborer digging the foundation for a Financial District high-rise discovered a gold coin minted in 1849 by the Miner’s Bank of San Francisco.
Readers do not even have to open the cover of James Dalessandro’s 1906 (2004) to know that the earthquake and fire play a major role in this novel. The dust jacket features a photograph of a devastated San Francisco street with the burning Call Building in the foreground. Marketed with the tag line “Every disaster has a backstory,” Dalessandro’s tale is told by young newspaper reporter Annalisa Passarelli. Annalisa is secretly assisting Chief of Detectives Byron Fallon to gather evidence of the graft and corruption of the city’s mayor, police chief, and political boss Adam Rolf (an obvious reference to the notorious “Boss” Abe Ruef). When Fallon is murdered, his son Hunter takes up the investigation. The earthquake hits just as Hunter, Annalisa, and a group of honest police officers are about to enter Rolf’s Nob Hill mansion to make the arrests. Rolf and his thugs use the ensuing chaos to turn the tables on their enemies and Annalisa and Hunter have to battle both the killers and the fire in order to save themselves and their city.
Locked Rooms (2005) is the eighth book in Laurie R. King’s long-running series about Mary Russell, the wife and partner-in-crime-detection of Sherlock Holmes. In 1924, Russell and Holmes are in San Francisco so that she can sell the Pacific Heights house that she inherited after her family’s death in an automobile crash ten years earlier. When an unknown assailant shoots at Mary, she and Holmes begin an investigation into the secrets of the long-shuttered house and her family. Holmes hires a young, ex-Pinkerton agent/struggling writer named Dashiell Hammett to assist him. Hammett quickly uncovers evidence that the “accident” that claimed her family was no accident—it was murder. Although all of the action in this novel takes place years after the earthquake, the solution to the murders eventually leads directly back to the chaotic days of April 1906, when extraordinary events caused ordinary people to commit drastic, and sometimes illegal, acts.
In the third novel in the Cree Black series, Bones of the Barbary Coast (2006), author Daniel Hecht blends historical mystery with the supernatural as a psychologist investigates a mysterious human skeleton from the 1906 San Francisco earthquake unearthed in the foundation of a fine Victorian home, uncovering secrets from the city’s infamous Barbary Coast through historical research and the 1889 diary of a woman with secrets of her own.
Anthony Flacco’s The Last Nightingale (2007) tells the story of twelve-year-old Shane Nightingale who survives the 1906 quake only to witness the horrific murder of his adoptive mother and two sisters at the hands of budding serial killer Tommie Kimbrough. After the fire destroys the Nightingale home, all evidence of the killings is erased, and Shane becomes just another anonymous orphan in the city. Before the quake, Sergeant Randall Blackburn of the San Francisco Police Department had been on the trail of a Barbary Coast killer nicknamed “The Surgeon” for the mutilation he performs on the bodies of his victims. When Blackburn meets up with Shane, the two become an unlikely detective duo. Shane has an unusual sense of intuition and deductive reasoning and Blackburn is experimenting with new methods of police work.
Shortly before the Great Earthquake, Pirate Vishnu sailed into San Francisco Bay. In Gigi Pandian’s second book in the Jaya Jones Treasure Hunt mysteries, Pirate Vishnu (2013), globe-trotting historian Jaya Jones is drawn into the story when she learns about a map of the Barbary Coast drawn by one of her ancestors who came to San Francisco from India and died in the earthquake. Her quest to uncover her ancestor’s secrets and decipher the cryptic treasure map takes her to India. Along the way she also has to solve two murders that took place a century apart and untangle a love triangle.
Rhys Bowen’s series heroine Molly Murphy ventures to San Francisco in Time of Fog and Fire (2016). After seeing a newsreel showing that her husband, New York City police captain Daniel Sullivan, is in San Francisco, Molly travels across the country with her young son. She discovers that Daniel is in danger and arrives just as the 1906 earthquake and subsequent fires devastate the city.
In the days before the great earthquake and fire of 1906, Levi Hayes returns from San Quentin Prison with a plan of revenge in Dietrich Kalteis’ House of Blazes (2016). After serving five years for the theft of $30,000 in gold coins from the San Francisco Mint, Levi is ready to take back what’s his from the now-powerful Healey brothers who set him up. Levi recruits his nephew, Mack Lewis, in a wild scheme that propels them through saloon halls, gambling dens, back alleys, and brothels before it backfires. In lock-up as the earthquake hits, Levi and Mack must escape the collapsing building and burning city to get to the gold coins, with the Healeys now after them.
Violet is one of three people grateful for the destruction of the big earthquake in The Two Mrs. Carlyles (2020) by Suzanne Rindell. The temblor leaves Violet and her two best friends unexpectedly wealthy—as long as the secret that binds them together stays buried beneath the rubble. A whirlwind romance with the city’s most eligible widower, Harry Carlyle, lands Violet in a luxurious mansion as the second Mrs. Carlyle. But all is not right and Violet soon finds herself trapped by the lingering specter of the first Mrs. Carlyle, and by the inescapable secrets of her own violent history.
As described in The Phoenix Crown (2024) by Kate Quinn and Janie Chang, San Francisco in 1906 is a city bustling with newly minted millionaires and scheming upstarts. Gemma, a golden-haired, silver-voiced soprano whose career desperately needs a boost, and Suling, a petite and determined Chinatown embroideress who is resolved to escape an arranged marriage, are two very different women hoping to change their fortunes. Their paths cross when they are drawn into the orbit of Henry Thornton, a charming railroad magnate whose extraordinary collection of Chinese antiques includes the fabled Phoenix Crown. His patronage offers Gemma and Suling the chance of a lifetime, but their lives are thrown into turmoil when the earthquake rips San Francisco apart and Thornton disappears. When the Phoenix Crown reappears five years later at a sumptuous Paris costume ball, Gemma and Suling are thrown together again in one last desperate quest for justice.
Susie Hara’s Earthquake Shack (2025) is her second novel featuring Sadie García Miller. Sadie’s not an ordinary private investigator. She doesn’t claim to look for missing persons or solve murders; she specializes in finding lost things. When her estranged cousin Al offers both money and information about her father’s mysterious death years before, Sadie agrees to take his case. His daughter Ruth’s house has disappeared—completely vanished! It was one of the original cottages, or earthquake shacks, built by the Army and the Parks Commission after the 1906 San Francisco quake to provide housing for displaced people. About 5,000 tiny wooden homes were constructed, all with redwood walls, fir flooring, and cedar shingles. They need Sadie’s help to find it. She soon discovers that there is much more at stake than just a missing building.
No comments:
Post a Comment